John’s of Bleecker Street

Coal-oven pies in wooden booths. Whole pies only.

Time there

1 hour

Best time

Lunch, to skip the line

Cost

Whole pies only, about $25–35

Good to know

No slices. Get the plain with black pepper. Station: Christopher St (1).

Also on these lists

WWhole pies worth the waitDDowntown and the Village on film

Next on this list

P3. Prince Street PizzaFood & drink · Village & Downtown›